Product I Regret Buying: Smashbox Jet Set Waterproof Gel Eyliner

I am typically a fan of Smashbox, but I can't even fake it with this eyeliner. I bought it in the color Navy Blue and have had it a while, however, I've only used it 3 times and that's enough for me. 

Each time I used it I used a different brush, two angled eyeliner brushes by both MAC and Sephora, and a tapered small pencil-like brush as well from a MAC gift set. None of them were successful in the fight against the uncooperative liner. Here is the most recent attempt:

The picture speaks for itself. The eye liner is a mess... no 'hot' involved.

Its crumbly, not smooth, dry (ever since the very first attempt), and leaves the ever-frustrating spotty effect. 

A very sad fail with this product and I wouldn't even consider re-buying.